There's "Wisconsin" in the air at Gabe Stulman's "hip" Village American, a tiny, "homey" thing where the "tasty" menu is as limited as the square footage; "divine oysters" and "attention to detail" offset the "not-Midwestern prices", though a few feel it's "more scene than place to eat."
Jeffrey's Grocery Restaurant Review:
Situated in an off-the-beaten-path space in the West Village, Jeffrey’s Grocery was immediately embraced by the area. That’s because restaurateur Gabriel Stulman seems to have perfected the art of the neighborhood restaurant (his other popular spot, Joseph Leonard, is across the street). Set up like a small market (hence the name), the restaurant is essentially a long bar and a communal table....
Gabe Stulman names corner spot after his dad, kits it out with vintage finishes. Stumptown coffee and baked goods by day, bar scene by night. Take a break from your Tumblr responsibilities with luncheonette options like lobster rolls and poached salmon salads. Cheese, charcuterie, craft beers, and champagne at the rail. Raw bar, because of course there’s a raw bar.