Lucys Whey

"Cheesemongers who care" offer a "personal shopping experience" at this "wonderful" little Chelsea Market fromage stall, an offshoot of the East Hampton shop that specializes in "top-quality" American farmstead cheeses "you won't find elsewhere" (no wonder it's "pricey"); if you "don't know what you want" they'll "happily cut you slivers" to try, and if you seek a party platter "they can take...

An American Artisanal Cheese Store with two locations, one in Chelsea Market and our newest location on the Upper East Side.
We carry only the best American farmstead cheeses, such as Jasper Hills, Cow Girl Creamery, Nettle Meadow, Consider Bardwell as well as provision such as pickles from McClure's, Anarchy in a Jar preserves and an assortment of sandwiches, such as our signature cheddar &...

Lucy’s Whey offers a large, carefully chosen selection of artisan and farmstead cheeses, all made in America. Each cheese is unique and presents distinctive flavors that reflect the farm, region and ingenuity of the cheesemaker.