When this nostalgic eatery opened in 1998, some locals complained that it wasn't nostalgic enough -- its decor harks to the 1950s, not the 1890s. They've since warmed up to it, however, probably because of the consistently good food and service. The distinctive features here are four cars: a 1950 Buick Roadmaster sits in the center of the dining room, flanked by a salad bar made out of a 1948...